hraness

saved

Why Are Some Octopuses So Smart? The Answer Might Lie in a Never-Before-Seen Mutation That Helps Them Accurately Build Proteins

by Sara HashemiSmithsonian Magazinepublished

gist

Researchers found an rRNA break in shallow-water octopuses that splits a usually continuous ribosomal RNA fragment in two. Putting the same break into E. coli roughly doubled protein-synthesis accuracy. All five examined incirrate species have it; a deep-sea cirrate and squid do not. That tracks the lineage with large, behaviorally complex nervous systems, but there is no direct evidence the mutation caused the expansion. Long-lived neurons are especially harmed by misfolded proteins, which is why the authors mention a possible therapy angle.

ideas

  • A conserved machine can still change. A unique rRNA break splits a usually single ribosomal RNA fragment and can double protein-synthesis accuracy in engineered E. coli.
  • The mutation tracks a behavioral lineage, not all cephalopods. All five examined incirrate species have the gap; a dumbo octopus and squid do not.
  • Correlation is not a brain-size proof. The authors and an outside biologist stress there is no direct evidence the rRNA change drove expanded nervous systems.
  • Protein accuracy matters more for long-lived neurons. Misfolding is especially costly in cells that persist, which is the proposed link to octopus intelligence and a speculative therapy path.

quotes

Although there is no direct evidence that the adaptation is linked to expanded octopus brainpower

Sara Hashemi, stating the missing causal link.

Inserting the same break in the ribosomes of Escherichia coli bacteria made the engineered cells produce proteins with about twice their usual accuracy.

Sara Hashemi, reporting the functional test.

We figured we were bad at extracting RNA

Nicholas Bellono, recalling the first interpretation of the rRNA gap.

We’re just getting to the beginning of genetics with these organisms

Joshua Rosenthal, cautioning that the evolutionary claim is not yet proven.